August 6th, 2007 at 8:42 am
(cage match)
Seiklus and Knytt are both serene platformers with more focus on ambiance and atmosphere than challenges. I’m sure that if both of them were thrown into a real cage match they’d make friends with one another instead of fight.
Vote for your favorite! (To enable easy vote-counting, please mention your vote as the first word of the comment.)
Vote count: Seiklus 16 - 25 Knytt
Previous results:
Warning Forever [27] - [29] Fraxy
Dwarf Fortress [73] - [21] The Kingdom of Loathing
Sumotori Dreams [8] - [44] Toribash
49 Comments
July 28th, 2007 at 7:04 am
(cage match)
Warning Forever. Fraxy. Both abstract shooters. Both centered around boss battles. Both very good games. But only one can win.
Voting is now closed, thanks for participating!
Vote count: Warning Forever 27 - 29 Fraxy
Winner: Fraxy
60 Comments
July 19th, 2007 at 10:23 pm
(cage match)
Voting is now closed, thanks for participating!
Vote count: Dwarf Fortress 73 - 21 The Kingdom of Loathing
Winner: Dwarf Fortress
“Kingdom of Loathing is hands-down the greatest web-browser game ever created. Dwarf Fortress can not compete with that. Can anyone even tell me why I would play DF over NetHack?” - Sebastian
“Dwarf Fortress is a clear winner. It’s the best game I’ve played in a long time. A huge amount of detail, rapid development. The perfect mix of Dungeon Keeper, The Sims and NetHack.” - VeaaC
“Not going to lie, KOL is pretty rockin’ with its humouristic D&D going on, but DF has stolen so many hours of my life it’s ridiculous.” - anonymous
“Never even heard of Dwarf Fortress… so, I vote KOL.” - Jonathan Ellis
“I’ve deposited quite a few hours into DF, and having to tell my dwarf lackys specifically what jobs to do, what things to pickup, where to put things you pick up, gets tiring. It’s like its not a god game, its a mothering simulator…” - anonymous
98 Comments
July 15th, 2007 at 3:39 pm
(cage match)
Voting is now closed, thanks for participating!
Vote count: Sumotori Dreams 8 - 44 Toribash
Winner: Toribash
“sumotori is far more entertaining and to crunch it all into 96k is herculean.” - Joe
“Toribash wins hands down, it’s both much deeper, much more developed, larger community and keeps you coming for more.” - Mahatma
“Toribash is just stick figures and elastic bands.” - Jim
“This sumotori looks like theft to me. He couldn’t even figure out a name for a game by himself.” - anonymous
59 Comments